Proposition 65: when you need a warning and how to write one

Marc HaddadForward Deployed Regulatory Engineer
Proposition 65 requires a business with 10 or more employees to give a “clear and reasonable” warning before knowingly exposing anyone in California to a listed chemical. No warning is needed if the exposure stays under the safe harbor level or another exemption applies. Whether your product needs one depends on the dose a person takes in, not on your bill of materials.
Key points
- A warning law: Proposition 65 isn’t a ban, so it decides whether you warn, not whether you may sell.
- Exposure decides: You compare the average user’s daily dose with the chemical’s safe harbor level, and the law sets no parts-per-million threshold.
- Four parts: A safe harbor warning has the yellow triangle symbol, a signal word such as “WARNING:”, a named listed chemical that is present in the product, and www.P65Warnings.ca.gov.
- Who warns: The manufacturer or another upstream business usually gives the warning, either on the label or through a written notice to the retailer. Online sales need their own warning.
- Old short form: Products manufactured and labeled from January 1, 2028, can no longer use the old short form (“Cancer – www.P65Warnings.ca.gov”).
What is Proposition 65?
Proposition 65 is a California law that requires a warning before a business exposes people to chemicals the state has listed for cancer or reproductive harm. It does not ban any chemical.
The warning duty is in Health and Safety Code section 25249.6, and the exemptions are in section 25249.10. The Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA) maintains the chemical list and writes the warning rules in Title 27 of the California Code of Regulations (27 CCR), while the Attorney General, local prosecutors and private enforcers bring the cases.
This guide covers consumer products, meaning any article “or component part thereof” sold for personal use.[1] Food, cosmetics, drugs, and environmental and workplace exposures have their own warning rules. Proposition 65 is one part of wider US product compliance duties.
Who does Proposition 65 apply to?
It applies to businesses with 10 or more employees whose products reach consumers in California, no matter where they ship from. A business with fewer than 10 employees is not a “person in the course of doing business” under the law,[2] but other businesses in its supply chain may still carry the duty.
Online sales count, because a retail seller includes anyone selling to consumers “by any means, including via the internet”.[1] Internet purchases also have their own warning methods.[3] A product sold only for workplace use is an occupational exposure and falls under the occupational warning rules instead.[3]
Who has to give the warning, the manufacturer or the retailer?
Usually the business further up the chain: the manufacturer, producer, packager, importer, supplier or distributor. It can put the warning on the label or send written notice and warning materials to the retailer,[1] and the retailer must then post what it receives.[1]
A retailer carries the duty itself only in these cases:[1]
- it sells under its own brand
- it introduced the chemical
- it covered or altered a label
- it received warning materials and didn’t post them
- it has actual knowledge of the exposure, and no upstream business has a California agent or place of business.
A written agreement between you and the retailer can split the duty differently, and it overrides these defaults.[1] Large retailers’ vendor terms often do this, usually with a notice and indemnity clause, so read the contract before the regulation.
Which chemicals need a Prop 65 warning?
Any chemical on OEHHA’s list needs one, starting 12 months after it was listed.[2] The regulations carry their own copy of the list.[3]
The table below shows listed chemicals that turn up in manufactured goods across industries, and when each was listed.
| Chemical | Where it turns up | Listed for |
|---|---|---|
| Lead | Brass, solder, PVC (polyvinyl chloride) stabilizers, some pigments | Reproductive toxicity (February 27, 1987); cancer, as “lead and lead compounds” (October 1, 1992) |
| DEHP (di(2-ethylhexyl)phthalate) | Soft PVC cords, tubing and grips | Cancer (January 1, 1988); reproductive toxicity (October 24, 2003) |
| Bisphenol A (BPA) | Polycarbonate housings, epoxy coatings | Reproductive toxicity (female, May 11, 2015; developmental, December 18, 2020) |
| Cadmium | Older pigments, plating, solders | Cancer (October 1, 1987); reproductive toxicity (May 1, 1997) |
| TDCPP, a flame retardant | Polyurethane foam | Cancer (October 28, 2011) |
| PFOA and PFOS (two PFAS, or per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances) | Fluoropolymer coatings, treated textiles | Developmental toxicity (November 10, 2017); cancer (PFOS December 24, 2021; PFOA February 25, 2022) |
The list keeps growing. On January 3, 2025, vinyl acetate was listed for cancer and bisphenol S for male reproductive toxicity. Warnings for both have been required since January 3, 2026, wherever exposure exceeds the safe harbor. Vinyl acetate is the monomer behind ethylene-vinyl acetate (EVA) foams and polyvinyl acetate adhesives.
Do I need a Prop 65 warning for my product?
You need one when the average user’s daily exposure to a listed chemical from your product is above the safe harbor level and no other exemption applies. Having the chemical in the product isn’t enough on its own.
There are two kinds of safe harbor level. For chemicals that cause cancer, it is a No Significant Risk Level (NSRL).[3] For chemicals that cause reproductive harm, it is a Maximum Allowable Dose Level (MADL), set at one thousandth of the no observable effect level.[3] Both are doses in micrograms per day (µg/day), not concentrations in the material.
- Lead: MADL 0.5 µg/day; NSRL 15 µg/day (oral).
- DEHP: NSRL 310 µg/day; oral MADL 410 µg/day for adults, 58 for infant boys and 20 for neonatal boys.
- BPA: MADL 3 µg/day for dermal (skin) exposure from solid materials.
Exposure is calculated for the average users of the product, not per head of population, and it counts only exposure from your product.[3] Children’s products and toys have no tailored warning text and no separate safe harbor. But the average user of a teething toy is a child, and DEHP’s lower MADLs for infants show how far that can move the threshold.
The law has no parts-per-million (ppm) threshold. The ppm limits in supplier specifications usually come from consent judgments (court settlements, which bind only their parties) or from retailer requirements.
How do you check whether a product needs a warning?
Work from materials to dose, and keep the paperwork.
- List the materials: Break the bill of materials (BOM) down by material, not by part number. Note each coating, alloy, polymer and foam, and ask suppliers to declare listed chemicals against the current list.
- Assess exposure, not content: For each listed chemical present, estimate the daily dose for an average user and compare it with the NSRL or MADL. Use wipe tests for handled parts and migration tests for parts that may be mouthed.
- Keep the file: It is your defense if a case comes.
- Re-test when things change: A new supplier, alloy or compound can change the dose.
The list also changes, since OEHHA publishes notices of intent to list on its Proposition 65 notices page and each final listing starts its own 12-month clock. Daptic tracks new Proposition 65 listings and flags which of your product lines they affect, so a new listing reaches the people who own those products while there is still time to test.
What must a Prop 65 warning say?
A safe harbor warning has four elements:[3]
- The symbol: a black exclamation point in a yellow equilateral triangle with a bold black outline. It may be black and white if the label isn’t printed in yellow.
- The signal word: “WARNING:”, “CA WARNING:” or “CALIFORNIA WARNING:” in bold capitals.
- The statement: names at least one listed chemical present in the product.
- The website: www.P65Warnings.ca.gov.
The full-length cancer statement reads: “This product can expose you to chemicals including [name], which is known to the State of California to cause cancer. For more information go to www.P65Warnings.ca.gov.”
The short form is a label method, and one version reads: “Cancer risk from exposure to [name]. See www.P65Warnings.ca.gov.”[3] If the warning covers both cancer and reproductive harm, name a chemical for each, unless one chemical is listed for both and the warning says so.[3]
Over-warning isn’t free, because a safe harbor warning must name a chemical that is in the product. A blanket warning naming chemicals you don’t use falls outside the safe harbor, and it doesn’t satisfy laws that cap content either.
The old short form (“Cancer – www.P65Warnings.ca.gov”) is on its way out. Products manufactured and labeled from January 1, 2028, can no longer use it, while products manufactured and labeled before that date may keep it whenever they are sold.[3]
Where does the Prop 65 warning go?
The method depends on how the product reaches the buyer, and the table below shows each channel’s method, allowed content and placement rules.
| Channel | Method (27 CCR 25602) | Content allowed (27 CCR 25603) | Placement |
|---|---|---|---|
| Product label (on the product or its immediate container) | (a)(3) or (a)(4) | Full-length or short form | Prominent and conspicuous (25601(c)); short form never below 6-point type |
| Shelf sign or tag | (a)(1) | Full-length | Product-specific, at each point of display; the retailer posts what it receives |
| Electronic, in store | (a)(2) | Full-length | Shown automatically before or during purchase |
| Catalog | (c) | Full-length, or the short form if the label uses it | Clearly associated with the item |
| Internet | (b) | Full-length, or the short form if the label uses it | On the product display page, through a “WARNING” hyperlink on that page, or shown prominently before checkout; never buried in general site content |
If the label or sign gives consumer information in another language, the warning must also appear in that language.[3]
The box label doesn’t reach the product page, so online sales need their own warning.[3] Until January 1, 2028, a retailer has 60 days to post an online warning after receiving your notice when the notice updates an old short-form warning to the new short form.[3] Send the online text with the notice.
How do you send a Prop 65 warning notice to a retailer?
Send it to the retailer’s authorized agent and get written or electronic confirmation of receipt.[1] The notice must:
- identify the product exactly (a universal product code, or UPC, works)
- state that the product can expose people to a listed chemical
- include all warning materials, including the online text.
Renew the notice every year, and if you add a chemical, or a cancer or reproductive endpoint, send a new notice within 90 days.[1]
Which products have their own Prop 65 warning rules?
Most electrical and electronic products, machinery and general consumer goods use the general warning method and content rules.[3] A few categories have their own safe harbor text:[3]
- passenger and off-highway vehicle parts, where the rules have been operative since January 1, 2025, and cover most parts but exclude tires, packaged service chemicals, parts containing asbestos, carpeting, upholstery, textiles and fabrics[1]
- diesel engines other than passenger vehicle engines[3]
- furniture[3]
- recreational marine vessel parts.[3]
What happens if you don’t give a Prop 65 warning?
You can be sued, most often by a private enforcer rather than the state. Anyone acting in the public interest can sue after serving a 60-day notice of violation on the business, the Attorney General and the local prosecutors. The notice comes with a certificate of merit stating that the enforcer consulted a qualified expert.[2]
If no public prosecutor starts and diligently pursues a case within those 60 days, the private suit can go ahead. Civil penalties can reach $2,500 per day for each violation,[2] and that arithmetic is why companies over-warn.
Court injunctions against the warning are narrow. The US District Court for the Eastern District of California has barred enforcement of the cancer warning on First Amendment grounds for at least four chemical and product pairings:
- Glyphosate: June 2020, with a Ninth Circuit opinion on November 7, 2023.[4]
- Dietary acrylamide: May 2, 2025, and the Ninth Circuit dismissed the appeal on May 29, 2026.
- Titanium dioxide in cosmetics: August 12, 2025.
- Diethanolamine in cosmetics: June 24, 2026.[5]
None of these covers the chemicals in the table above.
How does Proposition 65 relate to RoHS, REACH and PFAS laws?
They are separate, and passing one doesn’t answer the other. Proposition 65 decides whether you warn, measured by what a person takes in. Content restrictions such as RoHS (the EU’s Restriction of Hazardous Substances), REACH, TSCA (the federal Toxic Substances Control Act), the federal limits for children’s products and state PFAS laws decide whether you may sell, measured by concentration in a material. Content limits on finished products are covered under restricted substances.
Example: does a desk lamp need a Prop 65 warning?
This composite example shows how the steps apply to one product: a corded desk lamp with a powder-coated steel arm, a brass switch housing and a soft PVC power cord. The maker has about 140 employees and sells through its own website and a national retailer’s stores and website, so both channels reach California buyers.
The BOM pass finds lead as an alloying element in the brass switch housing and DEHP plasticizing the cord compound, while the powder coat supplier declares no listed chemicals.
Wipe testing puts the average user’s lead dose from the switch above the 0.5 µg/day MADL, so a warning is needed. The DEHP dose from handling the cord comes out below both the 310 µg/day NSRL and the 410 µg/day MADL, so the warning can name lead alone.
Lead is listed for both endpoints, so the box carries the short form: the symbol, “WARNING:” and “Risk of cancer and reproductive harm from exposure to lead. See www.P65Warnings.ca.gov.” It is printed at 6-point type or larger and is as conspicuous as the other text on the box. The company’s own product page uses the same text.
The retailer’s authorized agent receives a notice with three items: the box art, a full-length shelf sign naming lead for both cancer and reproductive harm, and the online text. The company renews the notice every year and re-runs the DEHP test when the cord supplier changes.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need a Prop 65 warning if my company has fewer than 10 employees?
No, a business with fewer than 10 employees is outside the law.[2] The duty can still fall on others in your chain, such as an importer or distributor with 10 or more employees, or the retailer when it has actual knowledge of the exposure and no upstream business has a California agent or place of business.[1]
Is there a ppm limit below which no Prop 65 warning is needed?
No. The law has no parts-per-million threshold, and the test is the average user’s daily dose against the NSRL or MADL.[3]
What does a Prop 65 safe harbor warning label look like?
It shows a black exclamation point in a yellow triangle, a signal word such as “WARNING:”, a statement naming a listed chemical in the product, and www.P65Warnings.ca.gov. A short-form label example reads: “Cancer risk from exposure to [name]. See www.P65Warnings.ca.gov.”
Can I still print “Cancer – www.P65Warnings.ca.gov” on my labels?
Only on products manufactured and labeled before January 1, 2028, and those products may keep that form whenever they are sold.[3]
Does the Prop 65 warning on my box cover my online listing?
No. Internet sales need a warning on the product display page, a “WARNING” hyperlink on that page, or a prominent warning before checkout.[3]
Who gives the Prop 65 warning on a retailer’s own-brand product?
The retailer, because when a retailer sells a product under its own brand, the warning duty moves to the retailer.[1]
Notes and sources
- 27 CCR Article 6, Clear and Reasonable Warnings: 25600, 25600.1, 25600.2, 25601, 25602, 25603, 25607.50, 25607.51, Subarticle 2 index
- California Health and Safety Code sections 25249.5 to 25249.13 (Proposition 65), official text: sections 25249.6, 25249.7(b), (d), (f), (k), 25249.8(a), 25249.10, 25249.11(b) and (f)
- California Code of Regulations, Title 27, section 25602(b); section 25606; section 27001; section 25705; section 25805; section 25821; sections 25601(b) and 25603(a); section 25603(b); section 25601(b); section 25603(c); section 25602(d); section 25602(b)(2); sections 25602 and 25603; section 25607; sections 25607.14 and 25607.15; sections 25607.12 and 25607.13; sections 25607.52 and 25607.53.
- US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, No. 20-16758.
- US District Court for the Eastern District of California, case 2:26-cv-00682.
Additional sources:
- Safe harbor levels: 27 CCR 25705, 27 CCR 25805, 27 CCR 25821
- Chemical list: 27 CCR 27001 and OEHHA, Proposition 65 list
- OEHHA, Final Statement of Reasons, Clear and Reasonable Warnings short-form amendments (approved November 26, 2024)
- California Attorney General, Proposition 65 enforcement and litigation
- Last reviewed: November 9, 2026.
This article reflects Marc Haddad’s independent opinions, not necessarily those of Daptic.



