Restricted substances: which chemical rules apply to finished products

Marc HaddadForward Deployed Regulatory Engineer
Restricted substances are chemicals that a law bans or limits in a finished product, or that you must report or warn about once they are inside something you sell. There is no single restricted substances list: the EU, the US federal government and individual US states each keep their own, with different thresholds, triggers and duty holders.
Key points
- The rules follow the product: chemical rules apply to finished products, not only to chemical makers, and each market keeps its own lists.
- Each rule measures something different: REACH’s 0.1% Candidate List threshold applies to each article inside your product, RoHS applies to each homogeneous material, and Proposition 65 looks at the exposure a person gets.
- Passing one test isn’t enough: a product can meet every limit and still owe a report or a warning.
- The duty stays with you: it usually falls on whoever places the product on the market or imports it, and a supplier declaration is your evidence, not a transfer of the duty.
What is a restricted substance in manufacturing?
A restricted substance is a chemical that a law limits or bans, or that you must report or warn about once it is in something you sell. Think of lead in a solder joint, a plasticizer in a cable jacket, or a PFAS (per- and polyfluoroalkyl substance) in a gasket. You didn’t make any of them, but all of them ship inside your product.
People are exposed to these chemicals while the product is in use and when it is thrown away, not at the chemical plant. That is why regulators put the duty on whoever places the product on the market: the manufacturer, the importer, and sometimes the distributor or retailer. Chemical rules are a core part of what product compliance covers.
Much of the law turns on the word “article.” In EU law, an article is an object whose shape, surface or design determines its function more than its chemical composition does.[1] A fan housing, a power cord and a circuit board are all articles. In the US, “article” is defined not in the statute but in the Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA’s) rules under the Toxic Substances Control Act.[2]
A rule can do three things, and many do more than one:
- Ban or limit: the substance may not exceed a set concentration, or may not be present at all.
- Report or notify: you tell a regulator what is in the product.
- Warn or inform: you pass information to business customers, or put a warning in front of consumers.
What are the main restricted substances regulations by region?
In the EU, the rules for finished products include REACH, RoHS and the POPs Regulation. In the US, they are TSCA at the federal level plus state laws, with California’s Proposition 65 working differently from the rest. Great Britain runs UK REACH and its own RoHS regulations, separately from the EU, and China, South Korea and Canada run parallel regimes with their own lists and duty holders.
EU REACH: Annex XVII and the Candidate List
REACH (Regulation (EC) No 1907/2006) applies to products in two ways. First, its Annex XVII restrictions apply to substances in articles, not only to chemicals sold on their own.[1]
Second, the European Chemicals Agency (ECHA) keeps the Candidate List of substances of very high concern (SVHCs). If an article contains a Candidate List substance above 0.1% weight by weight, you must give business customers enough information to use it safely, including at least the substance name. You must also answer a consumer’s request.[1]
Producers and importers may also have to notify ECHA.[1] The Article 33 information has also gone to ECHA’s SCIP database under the Waste Framework Directive (Directive 2008/98/EC).[3]
EU RoHS: electrical and electronic equipment
RoHS (Directive 2011/65/EU, on the restriction of hazardous substances) covers electrical and electronic equipment. Annex II restricts ten substances: lead, mercury, cadmium, hexavalent chromium, PBB, PBDE, and the phthalates DEHP, BBP, DBP and DIBP.
The limit is 0.1% by weight, or 0.01% for cadmium, in each homogeneous material.[4] A homogeneous material is one that can’t be separated mechanically, such as the insulation on a wire.[4] Annexes III and IV list exemptions that each apply for a limited time.
EU packaging rules
Packaging falls under its own regime: the Packaging and Packaging Waste Regulation (EU) 2025/40, which has applied since August 12, 2026. Its PFAS limits cover food-contact packaging only, so don’t stretch that limit to every carton, but don’t assume packaging is free of substance rules either.
US TSCA: federal rules that reach articles
TSCA (the Toxic Substances Control Act, 15 U.S.C. 2601 and following) is mostly about chemical substances and mixtures, and many of its notice and reporting duties exempt articles. The exceptions are what catch product makers:
- Section 6 rules: these can reach articles where needed to address the risk.[5] For example, since November 1, 2026, distributing articles that contain PIP (3:1) has been prohibited, subject to listed exclusions.[2]
- PFAS reporting under section 8(a)(7): this one-time report covers anyone who manufactured PFAS in any year from 2011 through 2022. Because manufacturing under TSCA includes importing, importers of PFAS-containing articles are covered.[2] Submissions open on January 31, 2027, or 60 days after a forthcoming final rule takes effect if that comes first.[2, 6]
- A proposed exemption: on November 13, 2025, EPA proposed exempting PFAS imported in articles, but it has not adopted that exemption yet.
US state laws: PFAS bans, children’s products and Proposition 65
States regulate products directly where federal law does not. Since January 1, 2025, Minnesota has banned intentionally added PFAS in eleven categories, including cookware, cosmetics and upholstered furniture. Since January 1, 2026, Maine has done the same for its own list of categories.
From January 1, 2032, both states move to a general ban on intentionally added PFAS, except for listed exemptions and for uses the state has formally found to be “currently unavoidable.”[7, 8] Other states have passed their own categories and dates, as PFAS laws by state shows. Several states also require makers to report or remove listed chemicals in children’s products.
California’s Proposition 65 works differently: it bans nothing in consumer products. Instead, it requires a clear and reasonable warning before a business knowingly exposes someone in California to a listed chemical, unless the exposure falls below the level the law treats as significant.[9]
The table below sums up what each main EU and US rule does, who holds the duty and which products it reaches.
| Instrument | Region | What it does | Who holds the duty | Products it reaches |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| REACH Annex XVII (Art. 67) | EU | Ban or limit | Anyone placing on the market | Substances, mixtures and articles, entry by entry |
| REACH Candidate List (Arts. 7(2), 33) | EU | Notify and inform | Producers and importers (7(2)); every supplier of the article, including distributors (33) | Any article above 0.1% |
| SCIP (Waste Framework Directive Art. 9(1)(i)) | EU | Report | Suppliers of articles | Articles above the Article 33 threshold |
| RoHS (Directive 2011/65/EU) | EU | Limit | Manufacturers, importers, distributors | Electrical and electronic equipment |
| TSCA section 6 | US | Ban or limit | Manufacturers (including importers), processors, distributors | Articles only where a rule names them |
| TSCA section 8(a)(7) | US | One-time report | Manufacturers, including article importers | PFAS made or imported 2011 to 2022 |
| State PFAS laws | US states | Ban and report | Mostly manufacturers; sellers too | Named categories now, most products later |
| Proposition 65 | California | Warn | Manufacturers, importers, distributors | Consumer products that expose people to listed chemicals |
How is the 0.1% restricted substance threshold measured?
It depends on the rule: REACH measures each article inside your product, RoHS measures each homogeneous material, and Proposition 65 looks at exposure, so it has no percentage threshold.
In a judgment, the Court of Justice of the European Union ruled that REACH’s 0.1% threshold applies to each article in an assembled product, not to the product as a whole.[10] A wire’s insulation is the homogeneous material under RoHS, while the insulated wire is the article under REACH.
On November 13, 2025, EPA proposed a 0.1% de minimis level for TSCA’s PFAS reporting rule (a floor below which reporting would not apply). That proposal has not been adopted, so the rule as it stands has no concentration cut-off.
The same substance can get different answers: a plasticizer can be allowed under RoHS while sitting on the REACH Candidate List and the Proposition 65 list at the same time. Clearing one list tells you nothing about the others, so check your bill of materials (BOM) against each rule separately.
Who is responsible for restricted substances in a product?
The duty usually falls on whoever places the product on the market or imports it. A supplier declaration is evidence that you have met the duty, but it does not hand the duty to the supplier.
In the EU, the importer of an article supplies it under Article 33 and notifies ECHA under Article 7(2). In the US, TSCA counts importing as manufacturing.[5] Under Proposition 65, the duty sits upstream with the manufacturer, importer or distributor. REACH and TSCA attach the duty to your role in the supply chain, so no contract moves it.
How do you check a product against restricted substances lists?
Start from what is in the product, then screen it against each rule at the level that rule uses, for each market you sell in.
- Build the BOM down to materials: part numbers are not enough, because you need the resin, plating, coating and plasticizer behind each part.
- Collect supplier declarations against named lists: ask about a specific Candidate List version, RoHS Annex II and the Proposition 65 list. A declaration that says only “REACH compliant,” with no list date, goes stale at the next update.
- Screen each line at the level each rule uses: that means the article for REACH, the homogeneous material for RoHS and the exposure for Proposition 65.
- Map by market: where each product ships decides which lists apply to it, and this map goes stale as lists, exemptions and state laws change on different schedules. Daptic tracks those changes across markets and works out which restricted substances rules reach each of your products where it ships.
- Keep records: save the declarations, test reports, SCIP submission numbers, Proposition 65 notices, and the version of each list you screened against.
Example: screening a desk fan for the EU and California
Here is how those steps play out for one product: an importer brings desk fans into the EU and California and works through the BOM line by line.
- Housing: the ABS housing uses a brominated flame retardant. Under RoHS, the housing plastic is tested for PBB and PBDE. REACH treats the housing as an article, so the flame retardant is checked against the Candidate List at the housing level.
- Power cord: the cord jacket’s plasticizer is not one of RoHS’s four phthalates, but it is on the Candidate List. It makes up about 5% of the cord’s weight and under 0.1% of the fan’s. The fan passes RoHS, but the cord is its own article, so Article 33 information goes to the importer’s distributors and a SCIP notification is due. If the plasticizer is listed under Proposition 65, handling the cord is an exposure to assess.
- Circuit board: the board uses leaded solder under a RoHS Annex III exemption, and that exemption’s expiry date has to be tracked. The RoHS exemption settles nothing under REACH, so the board’s components still need their own Candidate List check.
- US history: if the importer also brought fans with PFAS-containing parts into the US between 2011 and 2022, a federal TSCA section 8(a)(7) report is due as well.
To apply this to your own product, swap in your own parts and run every line through every rule for every market you ship to.
How often do restricted substances lists change?
Each list changes on its own schedule, so a screen is only as current as the list versions behind it.
- REACH Candidate List: ECHA updates it, and a declaration tied to an older version goes stale.
- REACH Annex XVII: the European Commission adds restrictions by regulation.
- RoHS: exemptions have expiry dates and are renewed or ended by delegated directive.
- TSCA: EPA adds article provisions through section 6 rules and significant new use rules, and the revision to the section 8(a)(7) rule is still pending.
- Proposition 65: California’s Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA) adds chemicals to the list.
- States: legislatures add categories and move dates every session.
Frequently asked questions
Is there one restricted substances list for all markets?
No. The EU, the US federal government and individual US states each keep their own lists, with different thresholds, triggers and duty holders. Where a product ships decides which lists apply to it.
If my product passes RoHS, does it meet REACH?
No. RoHS covers ten substances in electrical and electronic equipment, while the REACH Candidate List, REACH Annex XVII and Proposition 65 are separate tests.
Is the REACH 0.1% threshold measured against the whole product?
No. Under REACH, the 0.1% threshold applies to each article inside an assembled product, such as the power cord on a fan.[10]
Does a supplier declaration make the supplier responsible?
No. The declaration is your evidence that you have met the duty, but the duty stays with whoever places the product on the market or imports it.
Does TSCA apply to articles?
Only for some duties. Many TSCA notice and reporting duties exempt articles, but section 6 rules and the section 8(a)(7) PFAS reporting rule reach them.
Notes and sources
- REACH, Regulation (EC) No 1907/2006, Articles 3, 7, 33, 67
- eCFR: 40 CFR 704.3, part 705, 751.407, particularly § 704.3; § 751.407; § 705.10; § 705.20.
- Directive (EU) 2018/851 amending the Waste Framework Directive (SCIP), particularly Article 9(1)(i).
- RoHS, Directive 2011/65/EU and Delegated Directive (EU) 2015/863; European Commission RoHS page, particularly Articles 3(20) and 4(2).
- 15 U.S.C. 2602 and 15 U.S.C. 2605, particularly § 2605(c)(2)(E); § 2602(9).
- EPA final rule of April 13, 2026.
- Minn. Stat. 116.943; 38 M.R.S. §1614, particularly subd. 5.
- 38 M.R.S. §1614(5).
- California Health and Safety Code §25249.6 (Proposition 65).
- CJEU, Case C-106/14, September 10, 2015
Additional sources:
- POPs, Regulation (EU) 2019/1021
- Packaging and Packaging Waste Regulation (EU) 2025/40; Commission news, August 11, 2026
- Federal Register: proposed rule, November 13, 2025; final rule, April 13, 2026
- California Code of Regulations, title 27: 25600.2, 25602, 25603
- Last reviewed: November 9, 2026
This article reflects Marc Haddad’s independent opinions, not necessarily those of Daptic.



