Daptic announces $22M funding to bring compliance into product development. Learn More
Request Demo
Expert Authored

Why goods get held at customs over product compliance, and how to avoid it

Why goods get held at customs over product compliance, what detention, seizure and exclusion mean, and a checklist to keep the next shipment moving.
A product-style checklist card titled Pre-Shipment Checks with five checked steps for clearing customs, set on soft green horizontal bands.
November 12, 2026

Marc HaddadMarc HaddadForward Deployed Regulatory Engineer

 

US Customs and Border Protection (CBP) holds goods at customs when it, or an agency it enforces for, needs proof that a product may legally enter the United States. A hold is a decision about one entry, not a fine, and most product compliance holds are the importer’s to fix, with documents, testing or relabeling that cost far less before the goods ship.

 

Key points

 

  • CBP enforces its own import rules and the product rules of partner agencies such as the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC), the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA).
  • The importer of record must prove the product complies. The customs broker only files what the importer and manufacturer supply.
  • A hold can end in release, relabeling or rework under supervision, export, destruction or seizure, and the importer pays for storage and examination.
  • Since July 8, 2026, importers of products that need a CPSC certificate have had to file the certificate data electronically with the entry, and goods entered from a foreign trade zone follow from January 8, 2027.
  • Finish certificates, testing and labels before the goods leave the factory, because fixing them at the port is slow and costly.

Why are goods held at customs?

 

Goods are held when CBP or a partner agency won’t release them until it confirms they may enter. Merchandise selected for examination stays in customs custody until it has been examined and found to comply with US law.[1]

 

CBP enforces more than duties. It also applies admissibility rules set by other agencies, and it detains goods on behalf of agencies that decide whether a product may enter.[2] For a manufacturer, that means product safety, radio, emissions and vehicle safety rules are all checked at the border, through the data filed with the entry and sometimes a physical exam.

 

A hold is not a penalty. It is a decision about one entry, and it is separate from any penalty that may follow if the entry information turns out to be false.

Who is responsible when a shipment is held?

 

The importer of record is responsible. That is the party that makes entry, and it must use reasonable care to file correct entry information.[3] When a consumer product is made abroad, the importer is also the party that must issue its CPSC certificate.[4]

 

  • Customs broker: a licensed agent who files the entry for the importer. The broker transmits what it is given and cannot vouch for a product it has never seen.
  • CBP: decides admissibility under the customs laws, examines cargo and holds or releases it.
  • Partner agencies: set the product rules and decide admissibility for their products. For physical products the main ones are CPSC for consumer products, FCC for radio frequency devices, EPA for vehicles, engines and chemicals under the Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA), NHTSA for motor vehicles and vehicle equipment, and the Department of Agriculture (USDA) for plant materials such as wood. The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) covers food, drugs, cosmetics and medical devices, which have their own entry rules.
  • Foreign manufacturer: usually has no direct duty to CBP, but it holds the test reports, label artwork and design data the importer needs to answer a hold.

 

The practical consequence is that a broker can’t fix a product compliance hold. The fix sits with whoever controls the product’s testing, certification and labeling.

What do exam, detention, seizure, exclusion and redelivery mean?

 

These five terms describe different stages, and each changes what happens to the goods and how long you have to act.

 

  • Exam: CBP inspects the goods, from opening selected packages to unloading a container at a centralized examination station, a private facility that handles cargo for CBP and bills the importer under an approved fee schedule.[2] The importer pays to prepare goods for examination.[2]
  • Detention: CBP keeps the goods while it decides whether they may enter. For its own admissibility decisions, CBP must decide within five business days of the goods being presented for examination, and then send a notice within five more business days giving the reason, the expected length, the tests planned and the information that could speed things up.[1, 2]
  • Exclusion: a decision that the goods may not enter. If CBP makes no final decision within 30 days of presentation, the goods are treated as excluded, and that can be protested.[1, 2] A protest against an exclusion is due within 180 days of the written notice.[2, 5]
  • Seizure: CBP takes the goods with a view to forfeiture. Goods may be seized when their entry is restricted by a law on health, safety or conservation and they don’t comply.[6] A petition for relief is due within 30 days of the date the seizure notice was mailed.[2]
  • Redelivery: a demand to return goods that were already released, because they turned out not to be entitled to admission or not properly marked.[2] Failing to return them costs liquidated damages equal to their value, or three times their value for restricted or prohibited goods.[2]

What are the most common product compliance reasons for a hold?

 

Most product compliance holds come down to a missing or wrong document, a product that fails a mandatory rule, or a label that doesn’t match. The table shows the main reasons, who sets the rule, what proves compliance and how a hold is usually resolved.

 

Reason for hold Who requires it What proves compliance How to fix it
Missing or wrong certificate data for a regulated consumer product CPSC (16 CFR part 1110) General Certificate of Conformity or Children’s Product Certificate, filed electronically at entry Correct the entry data; produce the certificate and test records on request
Product fails a CPSC rule or ban CPSC (15 U.S.C. 2066) Test reports for each applicable rule, from a CPSC-accepted lab for children’s products Modify under CPSC and CBP supervision, export or destroy
Radio device without FCC authorization FCC (47 CFR 2.1203, 2.1204) Equipment authorization for the device, or another import condition Obtain authorization; otherwise export
Missing or wrong labels or marks CPSC, FCC, Federal Trade Commission textile labeling, CBP The label on the physical product and packaging Relabel under supervision; redelivery if already released
Chemical substance or mixture without TSCA certification EPA (19 CFR 12.121) Importer’s TSCA certification with the entry File the certification; articles only where a TSCA rule requires it
Vehicle, engine or vehicle equipment without declaration EPA (19 CFR 12.73), NHTSA (19 CFR 12.80) EPA certificate of conformity, label and declaration form; declaration of conformity with federal motor vehicle safety standards File the declaration; bring into conformity under bond, or export
Product description or tariff classification that doesn’t match the product CBP, with partner agency data requirements Invoice, description and classification aligned with the compliance paperwork Correct the entry and supply what the agency asks for
Wood or plant material without declaration USDA (Lacey Act) Plant and plant product declaration File the declaration

 

The reasons that apply depend on the product category.

 

  • Electrical and electronic, radio included: a radio frequency device may be imported only if it meets an import condition, usually a valid equipment authorization; narrow exceptions cover up to 4,000 units for testing and 400 for trade shows.[7] The FCC stopped requiring its import declaration, Form 740, on November 2, 2017, but the importer must still be able to show how it met an import condition if asked within one year of entry.[7, 8]
  • Children’s products and toys: these need a Children’s Product Certificate based on testing by a CPSC-accepted third-party lab, plus tracking labels on the product and its packaging.[9] A product without a required certificate can be refused admission.[10]
  • Machinery and industrial equipment: much of it sits outside CPSC’s consumer product rules, but an engine built into a machine brings EPA’s import rules for engines, and a radio module brings the FCC.[7, 11]
  • Vehicles, engines and vehicle parts: EPA requires a certificate of conformity, a label and a declaration form at entry, and NHTSA requires a declaration that the vehicle or equipment conforms to federal motor vehicle safety standards.[2]
  • Chemicals and products that contain them: TSCA certification covers substances and mixtures; an importer of articles certifies only where a TSCA rule or order requires it.[2]

 

Holds also come from import rules that have nothing to do with product safety. Goods must be marked with their country of origin.[2, 12] Goods made wholly or partly in China’s Xinjiang region, or by listed entities, are presumed to be made with forced labor and barred unless the importer rebuts that presumption.[13] Goods covered by antidumping or countervailing duty orders need the right case information and cash deposits at entry. Outside the US, the EU runs a comparable process in which customs suspends release and refers the product to market surveillance authorities.[14]

What happens after a hold, and who pays?

 

Read the notice first, because it says who is holding the goods, why, and what information would speed release. Then answer that specific reason with documents, not assurances.

 

The usual options are these.

 

  1. Supply documents: certificates, test reports, authorization grants or declarations. CPSC certificates must be produced within 24 hours of a CPSC or CBP request.[4]
  2. Test: CPSC may sample the goods, and CBP will release a representative sample for the importer to test at its own expense.[1, 10]
  3. Rework or relabel under supervision: CPSC can defer its decision and let a product be brought into compliance under bond, supervised by CPSC and CBP.[10]
  4. Export or destroy: a product CPSC refuses is destroyed unless export is permitted, and it is destroyed if not exported within 90 days of that approval.[10]

 

The importer pays. For products CPSC refuses, the owner or consignee pays storage, cartage, labor and destruction costs, and unpaid amounts become a lien on its future imports.[10] Terminal and carrier charges keep running while the goods sit.

 

Repeat problems cost more than one delayed container. False or negligent statements in an entry can bring penalties.[15] CPSC uses certificate data to score the risk of shipments, and it expects compliant filings to mean fewer holds and examinations, so a poor record draws more exams on future entries.[16]

 

Low-value shipments no longer avoid this. The de minimis exemption for shipments valued at $800 or less has been suspended since August 29, 2025, and on June 24, 2026, CBP made that suspension indefinite in its regulations for every mode other than mail, so they now need a formal or informal entry, and the statutory exemption ends on July 1, 2027.[17–19] CPSC’s electronic filing applies regardless of shipment value.[4, 16]

Where it gets complicated

 

  • The detention clock isn’t always CBP’s: the five-day and 30-day limits apply to CBP’s own admissibility decisions, not to detentions it makes for an agency that holds the decision.[2] When CPSC or FDA decides, their process sets the pace, so don’t plan around a deemed exclusion at day 30.
  • Release isn’t the end: goods that cleared can still be called back. FDA-regulated goods are released on condition for 30 days unless FDA extends that period, and other goods later found inadmissible can be demanded back until the entry is finally settled.[2]
  • Filing data isn’t the certificate: CPSC says it doesn’t intend to ask CBP to deny entry solely for failure to file electronically, and the system first sends warnings rather than rejections.[16] That does not make the certificate optional, because a product without one can still be refused.[10]
  • Supplier certificates don’t cover the finished product: CPSC component part certificates are voluntary and must not be filed with the entry.[4] The importer certifies the finished product, using component certificates as evidence at most. The FCC’s import rules also exclude most subassemblies and components, so the finished device is what has to qualify.[7]
  • The description is a compliance claim: agencies read the product description and classification to decide what data they expect and what to examine. A vague invoice line can flag an entry for review, or leave out data an agency expected, and either can cause a hold.

How do you avoid a customs hold?

 

Do the compliance work before the goods ship, and make the entry match it. Step 1 is where most holds start, because the list of agencies and rules for a product changes as rules are added or amended, and Daptic works out which requirements apply to a product in each market and flags the regulatory changes that affect it, which keeps that list current.

 

  1. List the agencies for each product: start from the bill of materials. A radio module brings the FCC, a children’s design brings CPSC third-party testing, an engine brings EPA, and a chemical shipped with the product brings TSCA.
  2. Get the certificate or authorization before the goods leave: issue the CPSC certificate for the exact model in the container, and hold the FCC authorization for the finished device.
  3. Test with an accepted lab where required: children’s products need a CPSC-accepted third-party lab.[9]
  4. Check labels on the physical product and packaging: check a production sample, not the artwork file.
  5. Align the invoice, description and classification with the compliance paperwork: the model numbers on the invoice should match the certificate.
  6. Give the broker the data early: CPSC certificate data must be filed when the entry is filed, either in full or by reference to a certificate in CPSC’s Product Registry.[4, 16]
  7. Keep records: CPSC certificate records must be kept for five years, and EPA vehicle and engine import records for at least five years.[2, 4]

Example: a connected toy held at the port

 

Here is an example of applying this to a product, a composite of common cases. An importer brings in a Bluetooth-connected plush toy for young children, made under contract abroad. The radio module has an FCC authorization, a CPSC-accepted lab tested the toy, and a Children’s Product Certificate exists, yet the shipment is held.

 

The CPSC notice gives two reasons. The certificate data filed with the entry listed the toy’s earlier model number, so the certificate on file did not cover the product in the container. The sample CPSC pulled had a tracking label on the box but none on the toy. Neither problem was about safety; both came from changes made after the paperwork was done, a new colorway with its own model number and a switch of fabric tag supplier.

 

The importer answered in three steps. It reissued the certificate for the new model number after its lab confirmed the colorway used the same tested materials, and corrected the entry data. It asked to relabel under CPSC supervision, which let the goods move under bond to a facility where every toy got a sewn-in tracking label. It then added a check of the production sample and the entry data against the certificate to its pre-shipment release.

 

The cost was time and fees rather than a fine: about three weeks of storage and examination charges, the labor to relabel every unit and a missed retail delivery window. A one-hour check before the container was loaded would have avoided all of it.

Frequently asked questions

How long can customs hold my shipment?

For CBP’s own decisions, it must decide within five business days whether to detain and make a final decision within 30 days of presentation, or the goods are treated as excluded. Detentions for other agencies, such as CPSC, follow those agencies’ processes.

Can my customs broker fix a compliance hold?

No. The broker files what the importer supplies, and the certificates, test reports and labels must come from the importer and the manufacturer.

Who pays for storage and exams when customs holds goods?

The importer does. It pays to prepare goods for examination and the exam station’s fees, and for products CPSC refuses, the storage, cartage, labor and destruction costs.

Will a missing CPSC eFiling stop my shipment?

Not by itself, according to CPSC, but a product without a required certificate can still be refused admission, and filing errors feed into how CPSC scores the risk of future shipments.

What happens if I can’t fix the problem?

The goods are exported or destroyed. A product CPSC refuses is destroyed unless export is permitted, and it is destroyed if not exported within 90 days of that approval.

Do low-value shipments still skip formal entry?

No. The de minimis exemption for shipments of $800 or less has been suspended since August 29, 2025, CBP made the suspension indefinite for every mode other than mail on June 24, 2026, and the statutory exemption ends on July 1, 2027.

Notes and sources

 

  1. 19 U.S.C. 1499, examination and detention, particularly § 1499(a); § 1499(c)(1); § 1499(c)(5)(A); § 1499(b)(3).
  2. eCFR: 19 CFR 151.16, 19 CFR 151.6, 19 CFR 141.113, 19 CFR 118.4, 19 CFR 171.2, 19 CFR 174.12, 19 CFR 12.73, 19 CFR 12.80, 19 CFR 12.121, particularly § 151.16(a); § 118.4(b); § 151.6; § 151.16(b); § 151.16(e); § 174.12(e)(2); § 171.2(a); § 141.113(a); § 141.113(i); § 12.73(b)(1); § 12.80(a); § 12.121(a); § 141.113(c); § 12.73(i)(5).
  3. 19 U.S.C. 1484(a)(1).
  4. eCFR: 16 CFR part 1110, certificates of compliance, particularly § 1110.7(a); § 1110.13(c); § 1110.13(a)(1); § 1110.19; § 1110.17.
  5. 19 U.S.C. 1514, protests, particularly § 1514(a)(4).
  6. 19 U.S.C. 1595a, seizure and forfeiture, particularly § 1595a(c)(2)(A).
  7. eCFR: 47 CFR part 2, subpart K, importation of radio frequency devices, particularly § 2.1203(a); § 2.1203(c); § 2.1203; § 2.1202.
  8. FCC, Authorization of Radiofrequency Equipment, FR Doc. 2017-23217 (November 2, 2017)
  9. 15 U.S.C. 2063(a)(2) and (a)(5).
  10. 15 U.S.C. 2066, CPSC imported products, particularly § 2066(a); § 2066(b); § 2066(c); § 2066(e); § 2066(f).
  11. 40 CFR part 1068, subpart D.
  12. 19 U.S.C. 1304(a).
  13. Uyghur Forced Labor Prevention Act, Public Law 117-78, Section 3.
  14. Regulation (EU) 2019/1020 on market surveillance
  15. 19 U.S.C. 1592.
  16. CPSC, eFiling Frequently Asked Questions
  17. Executive Order 14324.
  18. CBP Dec. 26-12, 91 FR 37789 (June 24, 2026), amending 19 CFR 10.151.
  19. Public Law 119-21, Section 70531(b).

 

Additional sources:

 

 

This article reflects Marc Haddad’s independent opinions, not necessarily those of Daptic.

Resources

Related Articles

Request a Demo Today